Joann Brand Check-up: Fixing the Debt, Not the Shelves
Joann, the Ohio fabric and craft chain founded in 1943, is set to close for good. A liquidator, GA Group, and the company’s term lenders won the auction for its assets, and Joann expects going-out-of-business sales at all of its roughly 800 U.S. stores, pending court approval. This is its second Chapter 11 in less than a year. We look at why the first rescue did not hold.
Key takeaways
- Joann’s 2024 bankruptcy removed about $505 million of funded debt but kept all of its more than 800 stores open.
- Supplier cuts and unpredictable deliveries of yarn and sewing items weakened the one-stop-shop promise that brought sewists and quilters in.
- Net sales fell from $2,762.3 million in fiscal 2021 to $2 billion in 2024, and the shares lost more than 99% of their IPO price before they were cancelled.
- For a specialist retailer, being in stock on core lines is part of the brand.
Download the full Joann Brand Check-up (PDF): vital signs, timeline, diagnosis, treatment and sources.
From IPO to wind-down in four years
Joann priced its Nasdaq IPO at $12 a share in March 2021, below a marketed range of $15 to $17. Its backer, Leonard Green & Partners, had taken the company private about a decade earlier. The numbers behind it looked strong. In fiscal 2021, which covered most of 2020, net sales rose 23.3% to $2,762.3 million.
The demand did not hold. In fiscal 2023, net sales fell 8.3% to $2.2 billion and Joann lost $200.6 million, including a $95.0 million impairment charge on its trade name. In our view, when a company writes down the value of its own name, the brand is already bleeding. Chief executive Wade Miquelon left in May 2023, and an interim office of the CEO took over.
On March 18, 2024, Joann filed a prepackaged Chapter 11 case to eliminate about $505 million of funded debt. Nasdaq suspended trading in the shares on March 28. The company emerged on April 30 as a private company, with no store closures or layoffs. The old shares last traded over the counter at $0.0759, down 99.4% from the IPO price, before they were cancelled.
The fix lasted less than nine months. Joann filed again on January 15, 2025, with $615.7 million in debt. A judge approved closing sales at more than 500 stores on February 14. On February 22, a court filing named GA Group, a liquidator, and a group of Joann’s term lenders as the winning bidders for substantially all of its assets, and Joann has said they plan to wind the business down. The sale still needs court approval at a hearing set for February 26.
Inventory shortages hit the core promise
Customers hire a fabric and craft specialist for one job: finding everything a project needs in one trip. After the first bankruptcy, Joann could not do that job reliably. Its second filing said suppliers had eliminated some products and deliveries of yarn and sewing items had become unpredictable. Interim CEO Michael Prendergast said in-stock levels eventually dropped by upwards of 10%.
Neil Saunders of GlobalData told NPR that suppliers grew reluctant to work with a company that appeared to be in trouble, and that frequent out-of-stocks pushed customers elsewhere. “A lot of stores were very shabby,” he said. For a specialist, depth of range is the brand. Once it thins, the reason to make the trip thins with it.
The restructuring fixed debt, not the store base
In March 2024, Joann said 95 percent of its more than 800 stores were cash flow positive, and it kept all of them open. Sales kept sliding, to $2 billion in 2024, down from $2,762.3 million in fiscal 2021, when it had 855 stores. Saunders said the reduced debt was “still quite punishing.” Less than eleven months later, about 500 stores were on a closing list.
Squeezed between bigger rivals and online sellers
Joann knew who its core customers were. In March 2024, Chris DiTullio, co-lead of the interim office of the CEO, said there was “no other retailer with the same ability to serve sewists, quilters, crocheters, crafters and other creative enthusiasts” than Joann. That claim holds only while the stores are stocked and kept up. Saunders said Joann lost market share to online sellers and to Hobby Lobby and Michaels. Hobby Lobby has about 1,000 stores and Michaels more than 1,200 in the U.S. and Canada. A specialist that loses its depth has no clear position left between them.
What growing companies can learn
Plan on demand you can keep. A boom year is not a baseline. Treat in-stock rates on core lines as a brand measure and report them next to sales. When you restructure, spend the breathing room on the experience customers pay for. Know which customers are your base, and protect what they come for first.
This check-up uses public information available on February 25, 2025. It is brand and marketing analysis, not investment advice.
Find out where your marketing is bleeding.
Brand Doctor is based in Vancouver and offers a free marketing diagnosis to businesses across Canada, in person or remotely. You leave knowing what’s holding growth back and what to fix first.
